Seasonal Aldi Price Comparisons

UPDATED: November 11, 2020.

'Tis the season for holiday food shopping. Here are some updated prices for the  post that appeared in 2018. Some prices may be regional, feel free to add your store's prices in the comments below.  

Click here for the latest Aldi price list and updated unit pricing! Also, for more prices, check out our newest site that allows you to search Aldi, including weekly Aldi Finds, Costco, Trader Joe's, and Whole Foods Market.  

Seasonal Spices & Extracts


NUTMEG
Aldi
  • Stonemill (1.5 oz.): $1.69, ($1.13 per oz.)
ShopRite
  • Badia (2.0 oz.): $1.69 $2.99 ($0.84 per oz.)
  • Shoprite Brand (2.12 oz.): $4.39 ($2.07 per oz.)
  • McCormick (1.1 oz.): $4.99 ($4.53 per oz.)
  • Organic McCormick (1.81 oz.): $5.99 ($3.30 per oz.)
Target
  • Badia (0.5 oz.): $0.89 ($1.78 per oz.)
  • McCormick (1.1 oz.): $4.39 ($3.99 per oz.)
  • Target, Market Pantry (0.9 oz.): $2.19 ($2.43 per oz.)
  • Good & Gather (0.9 oz.): $2.19 ($2.43 per oz.)
  • Organic Good & Gather (1.9 oz.): $5.99 ($3.15 per oz.)
Walmart
  • McCormick (1.1 oz.): $4.12 ($3.75 per oz.)
  • Great Value (2.5 oz.): $3.48 ($1.39 per oz.)
  • Organic Great Value (1.8 oz.): $5.94 ($3.30 per oz.)

ALLSPICE
Aldi
  • Stonemill (1.25 oz.): $1.69, $1.35 per oz.
ShopRite
  • Badia (0.5 oz.): $0.69 on-sale ($1.38 per oz.)
  • Badia (2 oz.): $1.49 on-sale ($0.745 per oz.)
  • McCormick (0.9 oz.): $4.19 ($4.66 per oz.)
Target
  • Badia (0.5 oz.): $0.99 ($1.98 per oz.)
  • McCormick (0.7 oz.): $3.59 ($3.99 per oz.)
Walmart
  • McCormick (1.1 oz.) $4.12 ($3.75 per oz.)
  • Great Value (2.0 oz.): $3.48 ($1.74 per oz.)
  • Organic Great Value (1.6 oz.): $3.97 ($2.48 per oz.)

GINGER
Aldi
  • Stonemill (1.1 oz.): $1.69, $1.54 per oz.
ShopRite
  • Badia (1.5 oz.): $1.49 on-sale ($0.99 per oz.)
  • McCormick Organic (1.25 oz.): $3.99 on-sale ($3.19 per oz.)
  • McCormick (0.7 oz.): $2.99 on-sale ($4.27 per oz.)
  • Simply Organic (1.64 oz.): $3.49 on-sale ($2.12 per oz.)
Target
  • Badia (0.5 oz.): $0.99 ($1.98 per oz.)
  • McCormick (0.7 oz.): $3.69 ($5.27 per oz.)
  • Good & Gather (0.7 oz.): $1.59 ($2.27 per oz.)
  • Good & Gather Organic (1.6 oz.): $1.99 ($1.24 per oz.)
Walmart
  • McCormick (1.5 oz.): $4.12 ($2.74 per oz.)
  • Organic Great Value (1.6 oz.): $3.97 ($2.48 per oz.)

GROUND CLOVES
Aldi
  • Stonemill (1.25 oz.): $1.69, $1.35 per oz.
ShopRite
  • Badia (1.75 oz.): $1.69 on-sale ($0.96 per oz.)
  • McCormick Organic (1.75 oz.): $5.99 on-sale ($3.42 per oz.)
  • McCormick (0.9 oz.): $4.99 on-sale ($5.54 per oz.)
  • Simply Organic (2.82 oz.): $5.99 on-sale ($2.12 per oz.)
Target
  • McCormick (0.9 oz.): $4.59 ($5.10 per oz.)
  • Good & Gather (0.9 oz.): $3.89 ($4.32 per oz.)
Walmart
  • McCormick (0.9 oz.): $4.57 ($5.07 per oz.)
  • Organic Great Value (1.8 oz.): $4.94 ($2.74 per oz.)
  • McCormick Organic (1.75 oz.): $7.94 ($4.54)

CREAM OF TARTAR
Aldi
  • Stonemill (2 oz.): $1.69 ($0.84 per oz.)
ShopRite
  • McCormick Gourmet All Natural (2.62 oz.): $3.99 on-sale ($1.52 per oz.)
  • McCormick (1.5 oz.): $4.39 ($2.92 per oz.)
Target
  • McCormick (1.5 oz.): $2.99 ($1.99 per oz.)
  • Good & Gather (1.5 oz.): $3.89 ($1.72 per oz.)
  • Good & Gather (3.5 oz.): $4.99 ($1.42)
Walmart
  • Great Value (3.9 oz.): $2.48 ($0.63 per oz.)

PUMPKIN PIE SPICE
Aldi
  • Stonemill (1.35 oz.): $1.69 ($1.25 per oz.)
ShopRite
  • McCormick (1.12 oz.): $6.99 ($6.24 per oz.)
  • Simply Organic (1.94 oz.): $3.49 on-sale ($1.79 per oz.)
Target
  • Good & Gather (0.75 oz.): $2.39 ($3.18 per oz.)
Walmart
  • Organic Great Value (1.65 oz.): $3.97 ($2.40 per oz.)
  • McCormick (1.12 oz.): $3.92 ($3.50 per oz.)


ALMOND EXTRACT
Aldi
  • Stonemill (2.00 fl. oz.): $1.99 ($0.995 per fl. oz.)
ShopRite
  • Badia (2.00 fl. oz.): $1.99 $2.49 ($0.995 per fl. oz.) this contains artificial flavors
  • McCormick (2.00 fl. oz.): $3.99 $4.99($1.995 per fl. oz.)
  • ShopRite Brand Imitation (2.00 fl. oz.): $2.69 ($1.35 per fl. oz.)
  • Simply Organic (4.00 fl. oz.): $5.49 $5.99 ($1.37 per fl. oz.)
  • Simply Organic (2.00 fl. oz.): $4.49 ($2.25 per fl. oz.)
Target
  • McCormick (2.00 fl. oz.): $3.89 ($1.945 per fl. oz.)
  • Market Pantry (1.00 fl. oz.): $3.29 ($3.29 per fl. oz.)
  • Watkins (2.00 oz.): $3.69 ($1.85 per oz.)
Walmart
  • McCormick (2.00 oz.): $3.88 ($1.94 per oz.)
  • Watkins (2.00 oz.): $3.44 ($1.72 per oz.)

LEMON EXTRACT
Aldi
  • Stonemill (2.00 fl. oz.): $1.99 ($0.995 per fl. oz.)
ShopRite
  • McCormick (2.00 fl. oz.): $3.99 $4.99 ($1.995 per fl. oz.)
  • ShopRite Brand (2.00 fl. oz.): $2.69 ($1.345 per fl. oz.)
Target
  • McCormick (2.00 fl. oz.): $3.99 ($1.995 per fl. oz.)
Walmart
  • Watkins (2.00 fl. oz.): $3.44 ($1.72 per fl. oz.)
  • McCormick (2.00 fl. oz.): $3.88 ($1.94 per fl. oz.)

  • PEPPERMINT EXTRACT
    Aldi
    • Stonemill (2.00 fl. oz.): $1.99 ($0.995 per fl. oz.)
    ShopRite
    • McCormick (1.00 fl. oz.): $3.49 $4.99 ($3.49 per fl. oz.)
    Target
    • McCormick (1 oz. fl. oz.): $2.49 ($2.49 per fl. oz.)
    Walmart
    • Watkins (2 oz. fl. oz.): $3.68 ($1.84 per fl. oz.)
    Author image
    About TJ